One of my pet linguistic peeves is the frequent misuse of the adjective proverbial.
Consider this sentence, from a magazine profile of a government whistleblower: “When she grabs hold of something, she is like the proverbial dog with a bone in its teeth.”
But the expression the writer cites is not a proverb; it’s a simile.
A quick Internet search reveals that just about anything has been incorrectly labeled proverbial: “sitting on the fence,” “in the hot seat,” “throwing in one’s hat,” “getting hit by a beer truck,” and even “the first post on a blog.”
Some dictionaries have shamefully capitulated, sanctioning this solecism. The American Heritage Dictionary, for example, gives this as its third definition of proverbial:”Widely referred to, as if [emphasis added] the subject of a proverb; famous.”
As I’ve cautioned in this column, however, dictionaries are not always to be trusted. Many are descriptivist, meaning that they simply reflect how words are commonly used, instead of giving us guidance on how they should be used.
A proverb communicates a truth, principle, or moral lesson in a pointed and pithy style: “Out of sight, out of mind.” “Politics makes strange bedfellows.” And, of course, “Early to bed and early to rise, makes a man healthy, wealthy, and wise.”
Whether adage, aphorism, apothegm, or axiom, a proverb contains a nugget of wisdom, expressed incisively and memorably. Thus, the word proverbial should be used only in reference to a genuine proverb.
So if you’re ever tempted to say something like “The report went astray, like the proverbial car keys,” ask yourself if what you’re referring to really is a proverb.
[Ed Note: For more than three decades, Don Hauptman was an award-winning independent direct-response copywriter and creative consultant. He is author of The Versatile Freelancer, an e-book recently published by AWAI that shows writers and other creative professionals how to diversify their careers into speaking, consulting, training, and critiquing.]
Similar Articles:
- The Language Perfectionist: What’s Wrong With Dictionaries? – "Let’s look it up in the dictionary." When people disagree about language, someone is boun…
- Word to the Wise: Solecism – “Solecism” – from the name of a city (Soloi) where a corrupt form of Greek was spoken – is a nonstan…
- The Language Perfectionist: Mixed-Up Expressions – Recently, a friend of mine, attempting to convey the idea that someone was naive, referred in an art…
- The Language Perfectionist: Quotable Metaphors – An incisive quotation can often make your writing or speaking more effective. But be sure that the o…
- The Language Perfectionist: Less Full Than Some – Consider these two examples, selected from thousands that an Internet search turned up: "Althou…
- The Language Perfectionist: A Misuse That Can Land You in Big Trouble – I can almost guarantee that you’ve read or heard this mistake: Website headline: Design a Fallout 3 …
- Words About Words – In this column, I routinely use words that describe aspects of language. But these terms are often m…