A frequent language question concerns the use of different from and different than. When do you use one or the other, and why?
The answer is easy – except when it’s hard! But let’s give it a try…
The phrase different from is correct when a noun or pronoun follows: "Girls are different from boys."
Here’s the explanation. A comparative adjective, such as bigger or better, takes than. But contrary to what some people assume, different is not a comparative adjective; it draws a distinction. So from is the right word.
But suppose a clause rather than a noun or pronoun follows. Here, different than is usually the superior choice: "The situation now is different than a year ago."
The common-sense reason is that when different from precedes a clause, it requires additional verbiage, and the result is often cumbersome or awkward. To be correct using from, the above example would have to be reworded as: "The situation now is different from what it was a year ago."
As with many disputed language issues, some permissive authorities insist that both different from and different than are "standard" and it doesn’t matter which is used. But I suggest taking the more cautious route and observing the above guidelines. What’s more, if you develop a good "ear" for language, that skill will often help you determine whether a construction is right or wrong. If it sounds bad, it probably is – and it should be rewritten.
[Ed Note: For more than three decades, Don Hauptman was a direct-response copywriter. He is author of the wordplay books Cruel and Unusual Puns and Acronymania, and is now writing a new book that also blends language and humor.]
Similar Articles:
- The Language Perfectionist: The Wizard of Was – What’s wrong with these sentences? “He acts as if he was the boss.” “What if war was outlawed?” “I w…
- Another Round of Confusables – As a lifelong blooper spotter and collector, I’m accustomed to encountering the most bizarre and amu…
- The Language Perfectionist: Use These Words Effectively – In a major business publication, I found this sentence: "Is the slowing economy effecting how b…
- Tough Grammar: Unusual Plurals – Making a singular noun into a plural one is first-grade grammar. Usually, you just stick an s (or es…
- The Language Perfectionist: How Bad Can Spelling “Bee”? – Certain words are consistently misspelled. Here are four examples I found in major newspapers, whose…
- Worth Quoting: William Safires Rules for Writing – Do not put statements in the negative form. Remember to never split an infinitive. It is incumbent …
- The Language Perfectionist: Me, Myself, and I – Usage experts agree that the pronoun “myself” has only two proper uses: the intensive and the reflex…